Showing posts with label fantasy review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fantasy review. Show all posts

Friday, August 5, 2011

Babymouse: Queen of the World (Module 6)

1. BIBLIOGRAPHY

Holm, Jennifer L. and Matthew Holm. 2005. Babymouse: Queen of the World. New York: Random House. ISBN: 9781415643990.



2. PLOT SUMMARY

Babymouse just wants to be popular (i.e. “Queen of the World”) and would do anything to get invited to Felica Furrypaw’s slumber party because Felicia is the most popular girl in school. Anything includes giving her book report to Felicia to turn in as her own and Babymouse ditching her best friend at the last minute. Babymouse finds out, though, that friends are better when they are made rather than bought and being queen is not about being popular but being loved.


3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS

This brother and sister team have a great style of allowing Babymouse to jump into fantasy scenes whenever her imagination takes her away. We get to see Babymouse living in fairy tales (Cinderella), deep space, a Western, etc. These secondary fantasy worlds add a great layer to the first fantasy world in which all animals talk, walk on two legs, and go to school together. The school itself is relateable to readers as it parallels contemporary times with lockers, classrooms, desks, and book reports.

Each page is filled with personality from the words to the drawings. Little descriptions, such as that Babymouse is “stuck with curly whiskers,” make the text fun to read. The black-white-and-pink illustrations are adorable and really bring life to the characters.

Kids will really get this graphic novel on the classic theme of friendship. The Holm’s bring a fresh take to it and allow for us to see that real friends do things for you, not just take from you, which is more important than being popular any day.

4. REVIEW EXCERPT(S)

  • ALA Notable Book
  • Booklist review: “The Holms spruce up some well-trod ground with breathless pacing and clever flights of Babymouse’s imagination, and their manic, pink-toned illustrations of Babymouse and her cohorts vigorously reflect the internal life of any million-ideas-a-minute middle-school student.”
  • Horn Book starred review: “Babymouse is here to stay, and fans of Fashion Kitty and Captain Underpants will now add her to their collection of well-thumbed volumes to read over and over again.”
  • Kirkus review: “Young readers will happily fall in line to follow Babymouse through both ordinary pratfalls (“Typical!” is her watchword) and extraordinary flights of fancy.”
  • Publishers Weekly review: “This personable, self-conscious mouse, with her penchant for pink hearts, resembles Kevin Henkes's Lilly, with some extra years of grade-school experience.”
  • School Library Journal review: “Babymouse, with her black-and-white-and-pink peppered palette, to anyone who thinks that comics are enjoyed primarily by boys.”



5. CONNECTIONS
  • 
Babymouse has her own fun website filled with games, a sing-along song, printable pages, and a make your own adventure. It also features information about graphic novels. This website can definitely raise what is already sure to be an enthusiastic love for Babymouse.
  • Suggested by the Babymouse website, Sidekicks is a graphic novel review website that will appeal to kids and adults. It can help kids find more of what they like and help parents, teachers, or librarians know what’s out there in the world of graphic novels.

  • Other graphic novel series sure to charm Babymouse fans: (Multiple ISBNs)

Holm, Jennifer and Mike Holm. Squish: Super Amoeba.

Harper, Charise Mericle. Fashion Kitty Series.

Runton, Andy. Owly Series.

Sonoda, Konami. Chocomimi Series.

Thursday, August 4, 2011

When You Reach Me (Module 6)

1. BIBLIOGRAPHY

Stead, Rebecca. 2009. When You Reach Me. New York: Wendy Lamb Books. ISBN: 9780385906647.



2. PLOT SUMMARY

Intertwining fantasy and mystery, the plot jumps around a bit in time, appropriate since it also addresses time travel, as we hear the story of twelve-year-old Miranda and the letters she has been receiving that foretell the future and also give seemingly weird instructions. The entire book is addressed to “you,” the person who has been sending the notes, and follows Miranda’s life as she loses her best friend, makes new ones, figures out who has been writing the notes, and learns what’s really important in life.


3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS

Following typical fantasy protocol, When You Reach Me features both a large task (time travel) and a sacrifice (giving of one’s own life, although I won't tell you whose). The author does a great job of creating a "real" life setting, consistently following its rules, and yet explaining time travel in a way that allows for its possibility. The ending is highly satisfying, pulling all the pieces of the puzzle and the ideas of time travel together. Each seemingly random detail falls into place by the end of the book.

Set in New York, Stead has created a vague contemporary feel, although from the beginning the time frame is clearly delineated as 1979. The setting in a big city is vital to the plot so that there is tension and slight feelings of danger with the existence of bullies and homeless on every corner as everyone is living in apartments and walking to places.

The main theme of really accepting the responsibility to do what is right is not preachy and is woven in with themes of friendship, loyalty, and coming of age. The voices of the characters are consistent with the tween age, and Miranda shows how she is maturing and growing from child to young adult.

Readers who love mysteries or science fiction or both will really get into this book and want to read it again once it’s all over to pick up on what was the subtle clues that were overlooked the first time through. I know I did.


4. REVIEW EXCERPT(S)
  • Newbery Medal Winner
  • ALA Notable Book/Best Book for Young Adults
  • Booklist starred review: “The ’70s New York setting is an honest reverberation of the era; the mental gymnastics required of readers are invigorating; and the characters, children and adults, are honest bits of humanity no matter in what place or time their souls rest.”
  • Kirkus starred review: “Some might guess at the baffling, heart-pounding conclusion, but when all the sidewalk characters from Miranda’s Manhattan world converge amid mind-blowing revelations and cunning details, teen readers will circle back to the beginning and say, ‘Wow...cool.’”
  • Library Media Connection review: “This well-written book is planned and executed to keep readers engaged until the very end. The author’s style is appealing because of her character development and clever plot vehicles. The topics are interesting and the short chapters keep the pace flowing quickly.”

5. CONNECTIONS

  • Random House’s website page on When You Reach Me has many helps for teaching this book including a video of the author and downloadable teacher’s guide. The teacher’s guide is 16 pages packed with wonderful information and help, including pre-reading activities, vocabulary, curriculum connections, and websites.
  • Madeleine L’Engle’s A Wrinkle in Time is featured throughout this book. Students, whether they have read it or not, will want to look over different parts of the book. It would be especially beneficial to read as a group the moment when Meg is returned to the garden along with the passage in When You Reach Me in which they discuss that part. 

  • Read alikes: (from Booklist)
Almond, David. Skellig. ISBN: 9780385326537

Creech, Sharon. Walk Two Moons. ISBN: 9780060233341.

Fitzhugh, Louise. Harriet the Spy. ISBN: 9780385327831.

Raskin, Ellen. The Westing Game. ISBN: 9780142401200.

Snyder, Zilpha Keatley. The Egypt Game. ISBN: 9781416960652.